Spotlight | Curley’s Bagels

Welcome to Broadway Stages' Spotlight, where we feature local shops, restaurants, organizations, individuals, and venues. We encourage our readers to consider supporting them to advance the local community. Today, we follow the hit show "Poker Face" to Curley's Bagels in Sunnyside Queens.

Fans of the hit Peacock show “Poker Face” have seen Natasha Lyonne's Charlie Cale solving crimes in a variety of settings in season one. From a luxury restaurant, a roadside diner, a barbecue joint, and an Italian family restaurant, you couldn't be blamed for developing an appetite for the hit show. Season two is being filmed now, and Broadway Stages can guarantee she will bring her unique style that will make you want to chew on more than just your fingernails! This month, the “Poker Face” cast and crew journeyed to one of our own favorite eateries, Curley's Bagels, in Sunnyside Queens.

This beloved neighborhood gem has been serving up some of the finest bagels in New York City for years, drawing in locals and visitors alike with its mouth watering selection, friendly service, and classic New York bagel experience. Whether you're a local, just passing through, or solving a murder, Curley's Bagels offers a welcoming spot to enjoy a bagel that truly captures the essence of New York.

Fresh Bagels and Tasty Sandwiches: Curley's Menu Highlights

Curley's Bagels is known for offering a wide variety of freshly baked bagels made from the finest ingredients and served daily. The bagels are chewy, perfectly crisped on the outside, and soft inside — just what you would expect from a top-tier New York bagel shop.

Popular options include everything from the traditional plain bagel to the loaded everything bagel with sesame, poppy seeds, garlic, and salt. Curley's also offers a variety of flavored bagels, like cinnamon raisin, chocolate chip, and poppy seed, to satisfy any craving. For those with a sweet tooth, the cinnamon raisin bagel with a sweet spread or the indulgent chocolate chip bagel is a perfect option.

The shop also serves a range of delicious spreads to complement your bagel. Classic cream cheese is a must-try, but Curley's goes beyond the basics with options like scallion cream cheese, vegetable cream cheese, and more. Many customers rave about the lox bagel, a classic New York deli staple that pairs perfectly with fresh bagels.

But it's not just about bagels — Curley's also serves up hearty bagel sandwiches for breakfast or lunch. One popular choice is the egg and cheese bagel sandwich, with options to add crispy bacon, sausage, or ham.  One Yelp reviewer writes, "I can't get enough of the bacon, egg, and cheese bagel. It's the perfect breakfast sandwich!" But there are also options like smoked salmon and cream cheese for those craving a more luxurious bite.

Curley's Bagels Hours: Perfect for Breakfast and Lunch

The bagel shop opens bright and early at 5:30 a.m. on weekdays, perfect for grabbing a quick breakfast before work or school. The shop opens slightly later at 6:00 a.m. on weekends, allowing a more relaxed start to your Saturday or Sunday. "I love stopping by for my morning bagel," says one Yelp reviewer. "It's my go-to spot for a quick breakfast on weekdays, and the staff is always so friendly. I never have to wait long!" Curley's Bagels stays open until 3:00 p.m. every day, ensuring you have plenty of time to enjoy a fresh bagel and coffee even if you're not a morning person.

A Friendly, Welcoming Atmosphere in Sunnyside

What sets Curley's Bagels apart is its incredible customer service and the sense of community that permeates the shop. It's not just about grabbing a bite to eat — it's about the experience. The staff at Curley's is known for being warm, welcoming, and efficient, making it a favorite among locals who often stop by on their way to work or during a leisurely weekend outing.

"I love the personal touch at Curley's," shares another Yelp reviewer. "The staff remembers your name and order every time. It's a great feeling to walk into a place where they know you. It's definitely a local favorite!"

The cozy, no-frills atmosphere at Curley's Bagels has earned it a dedicated fanbase. It's where regulars chat with staff and fellow customers, creating a sense of familiarity and connection that's hard to find in larger, more impersonal establishments.

Sunnyside's Hidden Bagel Gem: Community and Convenience

Curley's Bagels isn't just a place to grab a bagel — it's a local institution. Located in Sunnyside, Queens, the shop has become a beloved part of the community, offering delicious bagels and a welcoming environment that brings people together. Whether you're stopping by to pick up a quick bite or catching up with friends over coffee and a bagel, Curley's offers a sense of belonging to anyone who walks through its doors.

"Curley's Bagels is a staple in Sunnyside," says one regular. "The bagels are always fresh, and it's a great place to meet friends or start your day. It's one of those places you can't visit just once!" With its freshly baked bagels, mouthwatering sandwiches, and unbeatable atmosphere, it's no wonder that Curley's has earned such a loyal following in Sunnyside.

We at Broadway Stages have been enjoying Curley's Bagels for a while, and we were thrilled when “Poker Face” chose to film there. Curley's Bagels in Sunnyside, Queens, offers fresh, delicious bagels made daily in a variety of flavors, perfect for any taste. With hearty breakfast and lunch sandwiches, a friendly local vibe, and convenient hours, it's a must-visit spot for bagel lovers. While you are waiting for more adventures from Charlie Cale, why not get a preview of Curley’s Bagels? Learn more about them on Instagram and stop by today. You won't be sorry. And when you do, tell them Broadway Stages sent you!